Installing tub drain parts is one of those home jobs that feels small—until you spot water under the tub or smell that damp, musty odor. The good news is that a full tub drain swap (the drain plus the overflow connections) is usually a 1–2 hour project if you have access behind the tub or through a ceiling below.
Most skilled homeowners do fine with this job. Where people get into trouble is not the pipes—it’s the seal. A first-time bathtub drain installation or installing a new tub drain often leaks because the gasket or putty wasn’t seated right, or because the drain flange was over-tightened or cross-threaded. If that happens, don’t panic. In many cases, the fix is simply to take it back apart, clean it, and reseal it.
If you’re here because you’re asking, “Is it easy to change a bathtub drain?” the honest answer is: it’s usually easy if you can reach the connections and you take your time on the sealing steps. This guide starts with the most important “do-this-first” decisions—choosing the right kit and picking the right sealant—then walks you through removal, install, how to connect a tub drain to the overflow and trap, and how to test for leaks like a pro.
Installing Tub Drain: Fast Answer + Key Specs
If you want the fast version of how to install tub drain parts when installing a new drain, these easy steps cover the core process without diving into every detail yet: remove the old drain flange and shoe, clean the tub’s drain opening, reseal the new flange from above, tighten the shoe from below without twisting it, reconnect the overflow and waste tee, tie into the P-trap, then test with the tub full of water.
What a “tub drain” includes
A typical drain (often called a waste-and-overflow kit) includes the drain flange/strainer, the drain shoe (the elbow under the tub), gaskets and washers, a locknut, an overflow elbow/pipe, and a waste tee that connects the drain and overflow into one line to the trap.
Here’s the key point: even if your old parts look “fine,” it’s smart to replace gaskets, washers, and locknuts. Reusing old sealing parts is one of the fastest ways to end up chasing a slow leak later.
Time, difficulty, and what to expect
Most installs take 1–2 hours. Access and corrosion decide everything. A clean, newer setup with an access panel can be straightforward. An older tub with stuck threads can turn into a patience test.
For experienced DIY homeowners, success rates are often high. For first-timers, a noticeable chunk of installs leak on the first test because of sealing mistakes. The encouraging part is that most of those leaks are fixed by re-seating the gasket or redoing the putty/silicone and tightening again.
At-a-glance install map
Use this map to keep the parts straight while you work:
Flange (top of tub) → tub drain opening → gasket/washer (under tub) → shoe (elbow) → waste tee → overflow pipe/elbow → P-trap
When you’re under the tub, it helps to remember: the flange seals from above, and the shoe gasket seals from below. If either is off by even a little, you can get a drip that only shows up when the tub is full.
Choosing the Right Bathtub Drain Assembly
Before you open tools, make sure you bought the right drain assembly for your tub. Many people start with “how to change the bathtub drain,” buy a kit that looks right, then discover the pre-installed overflow height or pipe angles don’t match.
Drain stopper types and install complexity
Stopper style changes how you take things apart and how you set the new stopper height.
A push-and-pull stopper is common in newer tubs and is usually the easiest to easily install and adjust. You pull up to close and push down to open. A toe-touch stopper opens and closes when you press it with your foot. It has more small parts, and it’s picky about alignment. A lift-and-turn drain is common in older tubs; it often has a small set screw and can be confusing the first time you try to remove it.
If you’re stuck thinking, “How do I unscrew my bathtub drain?” your stopper type is usually the reason it won’t budge. Some drains unscrew at the flange; some have an inner post or insert that must come out first.
Compatibility checklist
You’ll have a smoother install if you confirm three things: tub material, pipe material, and fit.
If you have an acrylic or fiberglass tub, you must avoid over-tightening, because the tub can crack around the drain opening. Cast iron tubs are tougher, but the old metal parts can be more corroded and stubborn.
Next, check whether your home’s drain piping is plastic (common) or metal. Also check if the drain kit you bought is meant to connect by threaded joints, slip joints, or solvent weld (glued) connections. The sealing method changes depending on that.
Last, check the overflow height and the distance between the drain opening and the overflow opening. Many kits are adjustable, but not all.
Comparison table: stopper types
| Type | How it works | Pros | Cons | Best for | Notes (maintenance) |
| Lift-and-Turn | Lift slightly and twist to open/close | Simple, steady seal, easy DIY removal | Small screw/cap can catch hair | Most standard tubs | Remove and clean quarterly; check center screw |
| Push-Pull (Pop-Up) | Push down to close, pull up to open | Fast to use, clean look | Can trap debris under cap | Busy family bathrooms | Clean underside often to prevent slow drainage |
| Toe-Touch | Press with foot to toggle | Hands-free, good for mobility | Springs/caps wear with heavy use | Kids’ baths, accessibility | Replace worn seals/springs as needed |
| Trip-Lever (Overflow lever + plunger/linkage) | Lever moves internal linkage and plunger | Classic style, keeps stopper out of sight | Linkage can rust or misalign | Older tubs and replacements | Pull linkage to clean hair; adjust if it won’t seal |
| Cable-Operated | Overflow knob turns a cable to move stopper | Smooth look, no dangling linkage | Cable can bind if neglected | Modern/luxury look | Keep mechanism clean; replace cable if stiff |
| Flip-It (Drop-in O-rings) | Drop-in stopper uses O-rings; flip toggle | Tool-free, quick upgrade | Fit isn’t universal; O-rings wear | Renters or fast refresh | Expect O-ring replacement over time |
| Fixed Grid / Slotted | No moving parts; open grid cover | Minimal, fewer moving failures | Doesn’t fully seal for soaking | Shower-only tubs or “drain-first” use | Add a separate test plug when you want a soak |
| Pop-Up/Plunger variants (deep seal designs) | Internal plunger makes a stronger seal | Strong seal for deeper tubs | Some designs clog more easily | Deep-soak tubs | Plan on regular cleaning to prevent buildup |
Tools, Materials, and Sealants
This job is not about fancy tools. It’s about having the one tool that fits your drain and keeping your seals clean.
Essential tools (minimum viable kit)
For most tubs, you’ll want a drain wrench or drain key (often called drain keys), an adjustable wrench, pliers, a flathead screwdriver, and a putty knife for scraping old sealant.
A strap wrench can help if you don’t want to scratch a finished drain flange. A flashlight and small inspection mirror make it much easier to see gasket placement under the tub.
Sealants and tapes: what to use where
People ask this all the time: Should I use plumbers putty on bathtub drain? Often yes—especially under a metal drain flange—because plumber’s putty stays flexible and helps fill tiny gaps in the finish.
But there’s an important exception. Some plastic drains (and some tub makers) warn against putty because it can affect certain plastics over time. In those cases, silicone sealant is safer.
So, can I use silicone on a tub drain? Yes, as long as it’s a bath/kitchen silicone and it’s allowed by the drain or tub instructions. Silicone also makes sense when you want extra water resistance and clean, dry surfaces can eliminate the need for frequent resealing later. The tradeoff is that silicone is messier to remove next time.
Thread tape is another common confusion point. Use PTFE tape only on threads that are designed to seal by threads. Don’t use it on compression or slip joints that seal with a washer. If you tape the wrong thing, you can actually create leaks by preventing the parts from seating correctly.
Quick “tool quiz”
Answer these two questions before you start:
| Question | If your answer is “yes” | You probably need |
| Does your stopper have a tiny set screw? | Lift-and-turn style | Small hex key or screwdriver |
| Do you see crossbars inside the drain opening? | Flange uses a drain key | Drain wrench/drain key |
If you can’t see the crossbars because of grime, shine a light straight down and wipe the inside with a rag.
Step-by-Step: Remove Old Drain and Prep the Tub
Before installing anything new, the old drain has to come out cleanly. This step-by-step section focuses on how to unscrew a tub drain the right way, prep the tub opening, and avoid the small mistakes that lead to slow leaks later. Taking a few extra minutes here ensures the new drain sits flat, seals evenly, and won’t need to be redone after installation.
Safety + setup
Protect the tub surface with a towel so tools don’t chip the finish. If you have an access panel behind the tub, open it. If your access is from a ceiling below, lay down a drop cloth and keep a bucket handy. Even a small amount of standing water in the trap can spill when you loosen fittings.
If you’re working under the tub, you do not need to shut off the home’s water supply for this job, but you do want the tub dry and the area well-lit.
Remove the old stopper and flange
This is where people often get stuck on how to remove a bath tub drain without damaging the tub.
Step 1: Remove the stopper. For a push-and-pull stopper, lift it to the open position and twist the knob counterclockwise. Some styles have a small screw under the knob. For a toe-touch stopper, press it open, then unscrew the cap and remove the center shaft. For a lift-and-turn drain, Look for the stopper’s small set screw on the side of the knob and loosen it before lifting the stopper out. Loosen it, remove the knob, and then remove the threaded insert if there is one.
Step 2: Unscrew the drain flange. Now you’re at the part many people mean when they ask, “How do I unscrew my bathtub drain?” Insert a drain key into the flange and twist it counterclockwise; if it feels seized, turning it clockwise briefly can help break the seal before loosening. If you don’t have a drain key, a common trick is to use pliers on the crossbars, but that can crack old metal or slip and scratch the tub. If the flange is stuck, a small amount of penetrating oil on the threads (from below if possible) and a few minutes of wait time can help.
Step 3: Remove the drain shoe connection (if you’re replacing the full drain). If you’re doing a full replace a tub drain job, loosen the connection at the waste tee and overflow, then remove the shoe. Go slow so you don’t twist piping inside a wall.
Clean and inspect sealing surfaces
Scrape away old putty or silicone from the tub surface around the drain opening. Use a putty knife carefully so you don’t gouge acrylic or fiberglass. Clean the surface with mild cleaner and dry it well.
Look closely at the drain opening. Is the finish chipped? Is the surface pitted? Minor flaws are normal in older tubs, but deep damage may need extra care with sealant choice. A smooth, clean seat is what creates a watertight seal.
Install the Drain Flange + Drain Shoe
If you only slow down for one part of this project, slow down here. The flange seal is the #1 leak point after a new installation, even when everything looks tight.
Set the flange seal correctly
This step answers the big question, How should a tub drain be installed? It should be installed so the flange is sealed from above, and the shoe is tightened from below without twisting the flange out of place.
Step 1: Apply sealant under the flange. If you’re using plumber’s putty, roll it into a rope about the thickness of a pencil and place it under the flange lip. If you’re using silicone, run a continuous bead under the flange lip instead. The key is no gaps.
Step 2: Seat the flange. Drop the flange into the drain opening and press it down evenly. You want sealant squeeze-out all the way around, not just on one side.
Step 3: Remove squeeze-out cleanly. Wipe away the extra putty or silicone from the tub surface. If it’s putty, it’s easy. If it’s silicone, keep the cleanup neat because it will cure.
Align and tighten the drain shoe from below
Under the tub, place the correct gasket or washer on the shoe where it meets the tub. Then thread the shoe onto the flange. Hand-tighten first and make sure it’s spinning smoothly before applying any tools. If it binds early, stop—this is how cross-threading starts.
Once it’s hand-tight, use your drain key from above (or a wrench below, depending on the design) and tighten about ¼ to ½ turn past hand-tight. That small extra turn is usually enough to compress the gasket and seal the flange without cracking a tub or stripping threads.
While you tighten, keep checking that the shoe stays lined up with the waste tee connection. If the shoe twists out of alignment, it can pull on the flange and break your seal.
How tight should a tub drain flange be?
This is a common worry, and it should be. Over-tightening can cause damage that is expensive to fix.
If you have an acrylic or fiberglass tub, aim for “snug plus a little.” You want the gasket compressed, but you do not want the tub bottom flexing. If you have a cast iron tub, you can tighten more firmly because the tub won’t flex, but you still should not force it until metal squeals or threads feel rough.
A simple check is to look at the squeeze-out. With putty, you should see an even thin ring around the flange. With silicone, you should see a consistent bead line. Uneven squeeze-out often means uneven pressure.
Connect the Overflow and Waste Tee
A drain flange leak is easy to spot. An overflow leak can hide and rot subflooring before you notice. If you’ve ever seen a ceiling stain under a bathroom, you know why this part matters.
Install overflow gasket and overflow plate correctly
The overflow gasket is shaped to match the tub. One side may be thicker or beveled. Put it in the orientation that matches the tub’s curve so it seals when the overflow plate is tightened.
Align the overflow elbow behind the tub’s overflow opening, press the gasket into place, and install the faceplate screws. Tighten the screws evenly. If you crank one screw down hard, you can twist the gasket and create a channel for water.
If your tub uses a trip lever (a lever on the overflow plate), make sure the linkage moves freely before you seal everything up. A stuck linkage can make the stopper act weird later, and you don’t want to reopen the overflow just to fix a simple adjustment.
Connect overflow pipe to waste tee
Dry-fit your parts before final tightening so you can connect the pipes without force or misalignment. This is where you learn if your kit length and angles match your tub.
When you connect the overflow pipe to the waste tee, make sure the parts meet without force. If you have to shove the pipes sideways to make them meet, you’re building stress into the system. That stress often shows up later as a slow leak at a slip joint or at the shoe gasket.
Tighten connections firmly, but don’t crush plastic parts. If your setup uses slip-joint nuts with washers, the washer does the sealing—not raw strength.
Tie Into the P-Trap and Verify Code-Safe Fit
When you how to connect a tub drain search online, you’ll see many ways to do it. The “right” way depends on your existing plumbing and local code, but the goal is the same: a trap that holds water to block sewer gas, and a vented system so the trap doesn’t get siphoned dry.
Threaded vs. solvent-weld connections
Some tubs connect to the trap with slip joints (nuts and washers). Others connect with glued plastic pipe. With glued pipe, dry-fit first, mark alignment, then use primer and cement as required for the pipe type. Once glued, you have only seconds to set it, so planning matters.
With slip joints, confirm the washers face the right direction. Many are tapered. If the taper faces the wrong way, you can tighten the nut all day and still get a drip.
Slope, alignment, and access constraints
A tub drain line should slope slightly toward the drain so water doesn’t sit in the pipe. More important than exact slope is avoiding “bellies” (low spots) and avoiding stress. If the waste tee is being pulled sideways, it can slowly loosen the shoe or overflow seal.
If you discover there is no real access—no panel, no workable ceiling opening—stop and rethink before you seal a new drain flange. Some jobs become “easy” only after you cut an access opening. That’s not always a DIY-friendly choice.
Can I replace a tub drain without an access panel?
Sometimes. You may be able to reach the waste and overflow through the overflow opening itself, but full replacements are difficult that way. Another option is access from the ceiling below. If neither is possible and fittings are buried in a wall, it may be time to call a plumber, because forcing connections blindly can lead to hidden leaks.
Does a bathtub drain need to be vented?
Yes, a bathtub drain requires proper venting as part of the plumbing system to keep the trap from siphoning dry. According to the International Code Council (ICC), plumbing codes require fixtures such as bathtubs to be properly trapped and vented to maintain a water seal and prevent sewer gases from entering living spaces. The important detail for DIY work is this: you usually do not add a new vent when you’re just replacing the tub drain. The vent is typically already in the wall tied into the existing drain line. If your tub has chronic gurgling, slow draining, or sewer smell, that can point to venting problems, and that’s a bigger job than swapping the drain flange.
Test, Troubleshoot, and Prevent the Most Common Failures
According to the CDC, moisture and standing water in household plumbing systems can contribute to water quality issues and microbial growth, making early leak detection especially important. The best time to check for leaks is right now, with the access open and tools still out.
Leak test protocol
Step 1: Put a dry paper towel under each joint you touched: under the drain flange/shoe, under the waste tee connections, under the overflow elbow, and at the P-trap joint. Paper towels make tiny leaks easy to spot.
Step 2: Fill the tub until the water level is above the overflow opening, creating a tub with water under real soaking pressure. Wait 5–10 minutes. This tests the overflow seal and the drain flange seal under pressure.
Step 3: Drain the tub. While it drains, watch the shoe and waste tee. Flow can reveal leaks that don’t show up when the water is still.
Step 4: If everything stays dry, run the shower for a few minutes and check again. Vibration and temperature changes can reveal a weak seal.
Why is my new tub drain leaking?
If you did everything and still see a drip, you’re not alone. The most common causes are simple.
A top cause is reusing an old gasket or using the wrong gasket in the wrong place. Another is cross-threading the flange into the shoe. Sometimes the drain flange was tightened too little and needs a small extra turn. Other times it was tightened too much and squeezed the gasket unevenly, which means you must loosen, reseat, and tighten correctly.
Sealant choice can also matter. Putty under certain plastics can fail over time, and silicone applied to a wet or dusty surface can peel and leak. Clean and dry surfaces are not optional for silicone.
Leak location → fix (quick table)
| Leak location | What you’ll usually see | Most common fix |
| Around drain flange (top) | Wet ring at flange, drip below shoe | Remove flange, clean, reapply putty/silicone, reinstall |
| At shoe gasket (under tub) | Drip from shoe area when draining | Re-align shoe, replace gasket, tighten ¼ turn |
| Overflow area | Drip only when tub is full | Re-seat overflow gasket, tighten screws evenly |
| Slip-joint nut | Slow drip at nut/washer | Re-seat washer, snug nut, don’t tape washer joints |
| Trap connection | Drip during fast drain | Check alignment, washer direction, tighten carefully |
A simple rule helps: if the leak is at a seal surface, tightening alone might not fix it. If the leak is at a slip joint, careful snugging often does.
Costs, Lifespan, and When to Call a Plumber
It’s fair to ask if this project is worth your time. If your goal is saving money, it usually is—unless access is terrible or you find rotted subfloor.
DIY vs. pro cost (2025 ranges)
| Item | Typical cost |
| DIY parts (drain kit + small supplies) | $50–$150 |
| Plumber labor to replace a bathtub drain | $150–$400+ |
| Repairs if hidden damage is found | Varies widely |
So, how much does a plumber charge to replace a bathtub drain? Many homeowners see numbers in the range above, with higher totals when the plumber must open a ceiling, replace damaged piping, or repair subflooring from past leaks.
Lifespan and what fails first
A drain assembly often lasts 10–20 years, depending on water quality and how it’s cleaned. The overflow seal and overflow linkage can fail sooner because the gasket gets disturbed, screws loosen, or the linkage corrodes.
If you’re doing this job because of a recurring clog, it may be worth adding a simple hair catcher at the tub. Many “bad drain” complaints are really hair buildup.
When to call a plumber (the honest line)
Call a plumber if you can’t access the connections, if your drain piping is heavily corroded and feels like it could break, if you find signs of long-term water damage, or if the tub drain line seems to be unvented or improperly installed and you’re getting sewer gas smells. Also call if you have a freestanding tub with no practical access and specialty routing.
Freestanding tubs deserve a special note. If you’re trying to install a freestanding tub drain, check the manufacturer’s access method before you buy parts. Many freestanding tubs use tight spaces and special fittings. DIY is still possible, but planning matters more because you may not be able to reach anything once the tub is set.
Putty vs. Silicone: The Drain Seal Decision
This decision shows up in almost every tub drain job, so here’s the plain answer.
If you’re sealing a standard metal drain flange to a normal tub surface, plumber’s putty is often the easiest and most forgiving option. It compresses well, stays flexible, and is easy to clean off later.
If you have plastic parts or instructions that warn against putty, silicone is a safe choice when applied correctly. So yes, you can use silicone on a tub drain, but it must be applied to a clean, dry surface and allowed to cure per the label before heavy use.
If you’re unsure, check the drain assembly instructions and follow them. Mixing products or guessing is where people end up doing the job twice.
A Short Real-World Example
A common scenario is a slow drip that only appears when someone takes a bath. The shower doesn’t cause it, so it gets ignored. Then one day you notice the baseboard swelling in the room next door. When you open the access panel, the drip is right under the overflow elbow. The drain flange looks fine because it’s not the problem.
That’s why the “fill above overflow and wait” test is so important. It’s also why you tighten overflow screws evenly. One screw tightened more than the other can warp the gasket just enough to leak only under full-tub pressure.
Finish Strong: Your Final Checklist
Use this when you’re ready to wrap up:
-
Confirm flange seal squeeze-out is even all around.
-
Confirm shoe is aligned and not pulling sideways.
-
Confirm overflow gasket matches the tub curve and screws are evenly snug.
-
Confirm waste tee and trap joints are aligned with no stress.
-
Fill tub above overflow, wait, then drain and re-check every joint.
If you follow that, you’ll avoid most problems that lead people back to searching “test for leaks install” at midnight.
FAQs
1. Should I use plumber’s putty on a bathtub drain?
In most cases, yes—plumber’s putty is commonly used under a metal drain flange to create a watertight seal between the flange and the tub surface. It stays flexible, which helps prevent small leaks as the tub expands, contracts, or shifts slightly over time. That said, always check the tub and drain manufacturer’s instructions. Some modern tubs (especially acrylic or fiberglass) and plastic drain parts don’t play well with oil-based putty and may stain or degrade. If the instructions warn against putty, silicone sealant is the safer choice.
2. Is it easy to change a bathtub drain?
It can be easy, but it depends on access and condition. If you have an access panel behind the tub and the fittings aren’t badly corroded, many homeowners can swap a drain in under an hour. The job gets trickier if there’s no access panel, the drain is rusted in place, or the waste-and-overflow connections are old and brittle. In those cases, parts may snap or refuse to budge, turning a “simple” swap into a bigger plumbing project.
3. How do I unscrew my bathtub drain?
Start by removing the stopper—this step is key. Once it’s out, insert a drain key or drain wrench into the crossbars inside the drain flange and turn it counterclockwise. If it doesn’t move, don’t force it right away. Some drains (especially lift-and-turn styles) have a hidden set screw holding the assembly in place. Loosen that first. For stubborn drains, penetrating oil and steady pressure usually work better than brute force.
4. Can I use silicone on a tub drain?
Yes, silicone sealant works well for tub drains when it’s applied correctly. Make sure both surfaces are clean, dry, and free of old putty or residue before applying. Silicone is often preferred when plumber’s putty isn’t recommended or when sealing plastic components. Just remember that silicone needs proper curing time—usually 12 to 24 hours—before you run water, or the seal may fail.
5. Does a bathtub drain need to be vented?
Yes, bathtub drains normally require venting to keep the trap from losing its water seal and letting sewer gases into the bathroom. The good news is that if you’re only replacing the drain assembly, you usually don’t need to worry about the vent—the existing plumbing behind the wall already includes it. Venting only becomes a concern if you’re moving the tub, reconfiguring plumbing, or doing a full remodel that changes drain locations.
Reference
Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.